No, no, you're both wrong to judge him on that! He was brilliant. And I totally didn't know he was Meatloaf til the credits. He did a great job. He should in no way, shape, or form be deterrence from seeing the movie.

The way they messed with the ending, on the other hand... Otherwise the movie was a pretty decent adaption.

(Also, tacking my guess on the end here, I'm gonna guess either The Narrator or Tyler.)